Goodyear Welt Vs. Blake Stitch Vs. Cement, full guide on the differences between vegetable and chrome tanning, full length review of the Thorogood moc toe here, Red Wing vs Dr. Martens – Comparing Their Most Popular Boots, Why Filson’s Mackinaw Cruiser Is the Best Wool Coat of All Time, Kodiak Leather Bags Review: Pilot Bag vs Satchel, My 6 Favorite Jeans to Wear in Summer Heat, 2-Month Koio Sneaker Review – Why Italian Made Matters, Thursday Captain Boot Review – The Best Value Boot on Earth. Professional Shoes. Read next: Timberland vs Caterpillar Boots: Which Brand is Better? This attention to detail has made Thorogood one of the most famous “Made in USA” work shoe brands. How do they fit? In this comparison we will focus on the Red Wing Heritage Classic Moc vs the Irish Setter Ashby. The durability of the boots has played an important role in the success of the company which, at the beginning of the 20th century, also supplied the American army. (source). Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. I have the Red Wing version of that Carolina, and even though I wear them a lot, I wouldn't recommend them for something that doesn't require a lot of ankle support. Red Wing’s Iron Ranger shoes are also part of the company’s most popular styles. Timberland vs Woodland Shoes: A Comparison, 7 Swedish Shoes & Boots Brands for Cold, Rainy Weather, 9 Italian Ski Clothing & Gear Brands: Our Favorites, 7 Austrian Ski Brands for Jackets, Clothing & Equipment: Our Favorites. Because of this I find myself reaching for my Thorogood work boots more often than my Red Wings. They look fantastic and feel quality, but man are they uncomfortable! Thorogood boots are a much more comfortable when compared to my Red Wings. Thorogood vs Chippewa construction: Thorogood uses goodyear welting on all of their American Heritage boots. This section’s nice and quick: the prices can always change (especially if you get seconds) but roughly speaking, Red Wing is $280 and Thorogood is $200. To learn how we use your data when you comment, read our Privacy Policy. Red Wing is a shoe that I would recommend if you are less interested in what works best for electrician work and more interested in what looks stylish, ages well, and pays homage to the traditional ways of constructing boots. (source), Read next: Timberland vs Woodland Shoes: A Comparison. This can especially be the case with a brand such as Thorogood. 60 Last and the 87519s hug my feet really well while the Janesvilles are roomier. The sole, though, is where you might find Thorogood pull sahead. These are tough boots; you can wear them in rain and snow. The Red Wing's 23 Last is much narrower than the Thorogood No. There is also a subtle difference in price, as Red Wing is a little more expensive than Thorogood. 8 German Boots Brands for Hiking and Outdoor Activities. Relative to Red Wing, Thorogood’s sole is more lightweight and long lasting. I've owned a pair of Carolinas before, but not Thorogood. I enjoy the Thorogoods and would probably recommend them over the Red Wings, they’re just more comfortable and easy to get in and out of. What distinguishes Thorogood shoes from other products is their manufacturing which follows the Goodyear welt construction that is considered the best technique even if it needs more time. Then Thorogood has a removable insole made with what they call their Dual Density Ultimate Shock Absorption™. That means they may not last for a long time like their counterparts, the Thorogood boots. The boot is enriched with special stitching that make the aesthetics particularly interesting and refined, as the small details add value to the product. That there are a lot of subtle differences between boys and men but a well put together outfit with a sturdy pair of boots is one of the clearest signs that a guy cares how he is perceived by the world. For over 100 years the Red Wings company has been producing work shoes in the same way that the founder Beckman presented himself on the market with the first models. Good boots, but I'm a Red Wing fan. In our opinion, Thorogood boots are better for work also thanks to their resistant non-slip soles and safety features, while Red Wing footwear would be our choice for everyday life in the city. Finding the perfect work boots wasn’t always a challenge. You also have to consider the break-in period (usually not very long) and if you will wear them with thick socks. Asphalt Roofing. Let’s take a look! In either case, they’re beautiful pieces of American heritage and they’ll share your adventures for years to come. The following two tabs change content below. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Thorogood is more comfy out of the box, it’s cheaper, and it’s better suited for work. They offer so many different styles of boots, it can be hard to know which size you need. Let’s continue with some frequently asked questions: The majority of Red Wing boots are made in the USA using American materials at their facilities in Red Wing, Minnesota and Potosi, Missouri. This provides even more water resistance, so it’s got Red Wing beat in that category as well. The 875 is a fantastic, tough, and durable boot, but it’s not quite as recognized as a boot for work. We have picked these two pairs of boots by Red Wing: These Red Wing boots (Style 875) are among the company’s iconic and most requested models. Over time, Red Wing moc toe boots may give you longer wear and form to your feet a bit more, but five years in my Thorogoods have withstood a ton of abuse and only have a few scuffs that probably would’ve happened no matter what leather was on there. There is also a subtle difference in price, as Red Wing is a little more expensive than Thorogood. Considering their manufacturing process and the quality materials, Thorogood products have the right prices that allow you to spend what is necessary for a shoe that lasts over time and offers maximum comfort. The quality and commitment of the company has been key to its success and the significant expansion of its production in a short time. [Take a look at my full review of my first Red Wing moc toes]. However, unlike Thorogood, there’s no shank in the Red Wings. There is no special material on it, just a typical rubber outsole. The Thorogood brand is part of the employee owned Weinbrenner Shoe Company, whose history began in the late 1880s in Wisconsin, USA. If you want help deciding exactly which boots are for you, let’s talk! Of course, this depends on the model and your type of foot, because for example we have found people stating that they run a half-size smaller. For their boots, they use high quality leathers, following “the old way” to create an indestructible product. As an employee-owned company from Wisconsin, Thorogood® takes pride in creating high-quality crafted products designed for hard-working people around the world. 72% of their sold products are made in America. In 1964, the “Hike ‘n Camp” model (now the “814-4201” model) was launched. Readers, what do you think of these brands? Read next: Carhartt vs Dickies, Work and Outdoor Wear: A Comparison. Aesthetically — we’re just talking about appearances for now — Red Wing has a more subtle look. The resulting products are synonymous with good craftsmanship, resistance and durability. On average Red Wing boots cost around $250, with some models that can go above $300. Subscribe to our newsletter to receive our latest updates: To learn how we use your data when you sign up to our newsletter, read our Privacy Policy. Red Wing Iron Ranger Vs. Wolverine 1000 Mile – Which Is the Best Men’s Boot? Frequently mentioned in the frugal style circles of the internet as a “Red Wing killer,” these wedge-soled boots have a long American history. – Product images, if not otherwise specified, come from Pinterest.com or are our own creations. AMERICAN UNION SERIES – WATERPROOF – 6″ BROWN WORK BOOT View Details 804-3365 American Heritage – 8″ Tobacco Safety Toe – Moc Toe MAXWear 90™ View Details 804-4308 American… Red Wing has a more subtle, simple aesthetic, the leather is thicker and better quality, and it ages better. The sole of my last pair (8131) cracked after a few months of light use and since I do not live near a Red Wing store, I can’t easily get them repaired. Shop the boot here.] Redwing has been in the business of manufacturing footwear since 1905. Close. But, perhaps because they own their own tannery, Red Wing has better quality control and I consider their leather superior both aesthetically and functionally. Over time Red Wing has expanded its production not stopping at work boots but also producing Oxford shoes, hiking shoes and much more. Have you tried any of them? These are models that can be worn on various occasions, they are versatile but above all, comfortable and safe. Today the Red Wing Shoe Company, Inc. is still a privately-held company and still based in Red Wing, Minnesota. It’s really worth emphasizing that Thorogood also uses speed hooks and a leather pull tab, so it’s way easier to get on and off, making for an argument that the Thorogood is more “functional.” In the sole section below, you’ll also find a few other details that support this claim.