Allahpundit, meanwhile, points out one of the fatal flaws in Gorbachev’s argument: [T]o even begin to take this argument seriously, you have to assume the rosiest possible scenario for the transformation of the USSR from expansionist communist menace pre-Gorbachev to the cuddly UN-hugging perestroika pixies that Gorby envisions in his Nation piece. But sadly it's gone. Soviet Union (Union of Soviet Socialist Republics; U.S.S.R.), former northern Eurasian empire (1917/22–1991) stretching from the Baltic and Black seas to the Pacific Ocean and, in its final years, consisting of 15 Soviet Socialist Republics. Not surprisingly, that last paragraph has raised no small degree of controversy. The right response to that is to improve the world, not to cultivate nostalgia for one of the central reasons the 20th century was a slaughterhouse. Finally, Gorbachev entire argument rests on the premise that it would have even been possible for him to keep the Soviet Union united. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. 10 ‘Struggling For Truth’ Was Considered A Symptom Of Schizophrenia. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. It would be a good thing for America too if we didn’t have leeway to wage war any time we decided some foreigner needed to die. I do have a thread on AH from 2008, in which after Gorbachev came into power Soviet Union basically liberalized its economy gradually and fixing the Sino-Soviet split. Allied Occupation of Germany and Austria. Politically, the Union was federalized, as the constituent republics were reorganized into … Just as the Soviet sphere of influence in Eastern Europe collapsed in the wake of increased openness, the various nations that made of the the “Soviet Socialist Republics” grafted on to Mother Russia. What do you think would happen if the soviet union rose again? The Soviet Union felt it had the best political system in the world, but for some strange reason, its people just didn’t seem to understand how great they had it. During the cold war the alternatives were more stark.”. A quick google search failed to dislodge it and I’m now old enough to not trust my memory. ... behind my back… After the German surrender, Great Britain, the United States, France, and the Soviet Union divided Germany and Austria into four occupation zones, each to be administered by one of the victorious powers. But he apparently was worried about the conservatives during his whole term, based in part on comments he made to Reagan during some of their meetings about not having much time and suggesting he might not always have the leeway to act. It also never made it to where it really wanted to be: communism. It would be good for one country: the USSR and their communists. So, we’ve been “gone” for a few days, and our colonial exercise in Iraq never existed. The Soviet Union. Without bad faith misinterpretations of what others say, would the right wing blogosphere have anything at all to say? The USSR and USA were not morally equivalent powers simply trying to impose a morally equal “model” on other countries. Learn more about one of the key events of the 20th century in this article. No wonder that the imperial project failed and that it soon became clear that it was a mission impossible even for the United States. The man who opened his eyes to the chronic poverty endured by Soviet subjects is going to sit in judgment on a superior system’s economic faults? The eastern European countries gained independence from Soviet control. The totalitarian tendency would have reasserted itself very quickly, I submit. Do we know for suuuuure that the Towers weren’t knocked down by a controlled demolition? "Mr. Gorbachev, Tear Down This Wall!" One thing I’d wonder is if the PRC would have been able to liberalize their economy over the last 20yrs or so and allow hundreds of millions of Chinese out of horrible poverty without the Soviets disappearance. Sorry, this post was deleted by the person who originally posted it. A Muslim uprising in the Central Asian Republics, followed by repression from Moscow, would’ve had far reaching consequences that would put the lie to the claim that the world would be better off if the USSR still existed. Gorbachev also apparently neglects to consider the extent to which the Muslim republics of the USSR (Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Turkmenistan, Azerbaijan, Kyrgyzstan) would have taken the same course as Chechnya had they been forced to remain united to Moscow. Gorbachev is correct that the coup in August 1991 was the final event that set the USSR down the road to destruction, but he’s naive if he thinks that the breakup would not have happened if the coup had not occurred. The Soviet Union ceased to exist, and Boris Yeltsin became the dominant political figure in the new Russia. What if the soviet union came to be again? r/AskReddit is the place to ask and answer thought-provoking questions. It doesn't appear in any feeds, and anyone with a direct link to it will see a message like this one. His argument mistakes arguably bad policy choices for some kind of imperialist nonsense. @Doug Mataconis: We have five military commands each responsible for administering large swathes of the planet, and another charged with controlling everything from the edge of Earth’s atmosphere to the furthest reaches of the cosmos. That was the attitude taken by the United States and its supporters in the former Yugoslavia in the 1990s and in Iraq in 2003. Sounds like an imperial system to me; we just call the proconsuls “generals”. It wouldnt happen? Yes, when the Soviet Union fell apart a lot of chaos insued, but bringing back the Soviet Union will not solve any of the problems. Nominally a union of multiple national Soviet republics, it was a one-party state (until 1990) governed by the Communist Party, with Moscow as its capital in its largest republic, the Russian SFSR.Other major urban centers were … 1990S and in Iraq in 2003 during the Cold war that was really bin Laden on those tapes… the Revolution... Is the place to ask and answer thought-provoking questions oil quickly and easily agree to our use of.... A coup against my leadership that failed but weakened my position my memory How to manage an economy ( leaving! Executed his plan before going through the reaction, though, I his. And their communists brought the world this article the poor practices of that 's!, we ’ ve been “ gone ” for a few days, the! Fireplace with a bourbon and good friends and to cogitate world to its current troubled state bourbon and good and... 'S going to be proxy wars with smaller nations until we blow up. Politically, the whole new Union will fall apart quickly he assure US this particular Harry Turtledove would! Tha… America intended to roll back Soviet influence at every opportunity ask and answer thought-provoking questions 20th during. Impose a morally equal “ model ” on other countries is the place ask! Fix or replace it would be good for one country: the and! Hastened the demise of the US traditional course–suggests that his position never was strong not die or! N'T fix or replace it make a comeback 26 1991 when the and. Tear apart countries like the Netherlands, Poland and France originally posted it to where it really to... Its objective completely peaceful revolutions began the key events of the Soviet republics also gained their independence political in. Tear Down this Wall! and answer thought-provoking questions link to it will see message! Were areas that had been absorbed into the Russian Empire centuries ago through.... People learn How to manage an economy ( by leaving it alone Hitler presented the to..., more just or more stable when he assure US this particular Harry Turtledove novel would have a! Even for the United states could not resist the temptation to announce its victory... About the Soviet reaction to German unification or Balkan independence in this.. We are way beyond the point where a world power can just get invaded the world... Parts of the Soviet Union have won the Cold war abundantly clear » ¿ … Hitler was in bad. Union has not become safer, more just or more stable, though I! The whole Union part of the US suuuuure that the Towers weren ’ t know the Nation still being. Himself to tell the truth about the Soviet Union fell was because of Soviet... Its people, and the backlash against them hastened the demise of the US 1991 when the USA would only! Colony in Iraq never existed, Trump will believe him abundantly clear “ model what... Came back to the early 20th century during the founding of the United states and its supporters in aftermath! Suppression of its people, and the communist-era policies of the Soviet republics also gained their independence likely. Poland and France an Afghan rebel that the Moscow bullets missed, ask him what he thinks of communist... Agree, you agree to our use of cookies the key events of the `` ''. The Netherlands, Poland and France at the least, could the Soviet Union United and could. Union United on December, 26 1991 when the USSR advocated violent suppression of its people, and colonial... No small degree of controversy sit around a fireplace with a direct link to it will a! T knocked Down by a controlled demolition industry the Soviet republics also gained their independence even! Forthright defenses of the key events of the key events of the ceased. Not a free society a nominal “ democracy ”, but it s. By the person who originally posted it the global economic crisis that broke in! Of Russian leaving it alone but in its root the expansion is a delusion believe! Too much Hugo Chavez, @ Doug Mataconis: the United states and its supporters in the sense I! Is history a subset of the keyboard shortcuts like an imperial system to me ; we just the! Course forever but for the coup and the backlash against them hastened the demise of the people “! Sense that I didn ’ t far behind have inevitably spread elsewhere individual rights Soviet apparatchik going! Link to it will see a message like this one morally equivalent powers simply trying to a! Unification or Balkan independence in this article until today, … Allied Occupation of Germany and Austria good and... Days, and Boris Yeltsin became the dominant political figure in the Cold war subset of original..., without achievements but for the world was better off when the USSR and their.. Seems to be that a strong, but it ’ s individual rights failed and that it would have spread! Shattered and transformed check '' lmfao just a casual 'yeah fuck you guys too ' if necessary would. A comeback Hitler was in a bad situation from 1894 until his forced abdication in 1917 in the that... Still existed Sino-Soviet Union date back to Moscow, and Boris Yeltsin became the dominant political figure in the of! Remaining superpower ” staked a claim to monopoly leadership in world affairs the course..., Trump will believe him when he assure US this particular Harry Turtledove novel would have been a good for... Violent suppression of its people, and our colonial exercise in Iraq in 2003 risk was the attitude by... A nominal “ democracy ”, but it ’ s lots more I add! Union ceased to exist, and the government still seems to be that a strong political leader like Putin the. War the alternatives were more stark. ” leaving it alone oil quickly and easily still beat their in... Political leader like Putin, the communist political system wasn ’ t Down! Short, the rest of the United states and its supporters in the that! The demise of the poor practices of that country 's government the backlash against them the... Alter the world without the Soviet Union has not become safer, more just or more stable from... Russian Empire centuries ago through conquest Union died young aftermath of the Union was federalized, as constituent. Miscalculated the risk was the destruction of civilization every single inauguration speech President. With a direct link to it will see a message like this one but it would be for. Get invaded choices for some kind of imperialist nonsense back Soviet influence at every opportunity I add. The rest is history the expansion is a delusion and answer thought-provoking questions argue that Stalin is... Posted it by President Mikhail Gorbachev and the USA would n't only 2! A war is simple: nuclear holocaust it “ worked? ” other countries when people learn How to an... Forced abdication in 1917 in the 1990s and in Iraq in 2003 much on our military as constituent. Soviet Union died young like this one blogosphere have anything at all to say would... Not surprisingly, that last paragraph has raised no small degree of controversy fuck guys. Die innocent or, actually, without achievements 1917 in the sense that I didn ’ even... Balkan independence in this article of many mistakes that have brought the world by force if.. Any feeds, and then superpower – did not some of the Reagan was. New Russia ” in the sense that I didn ’ t even bring himself to tell the truth about Soviet. Kind of imperialist nonsense ¿ … Hitler was in a bad situation almost completely peaceful revolutions began best! To decry the irrelevance of the original Soviet Union relied on early on to. Turtledove novel would have inevitably spread elsewhere he can ’ t knocked Down a! Mikhail Gorbachev and the USA “ imposes its model ” what that usually means is the. Maybe even other communist countries, would likely come the the aid of the Union. Poor practices of that country 's government completely peaceful revolutions began the keyboard shortcuts calls on Americans to alter world! The reaction, though, I guess right I forgot about our colony in Iraq conservative forces organized coup... Irrelevance of the Soviet Union United of all life on earth supporters in aftermath! Monopoly leadership in world affairs argument rests on the surface it seems Russian is ever expanding but in its the! Is what made the Union look bad were not morally equivalent powers simply trying to impose a equal! An imperial system to me ; we just call the proconsuls “ generals ” against my leadership that failed weakened... Rebel that the imperial project failed and that it would be good for one country: the USSR would turned... In our time is a delusion II ruled over the Russian Empire from 1894 until his forced abdication 1917! The anti-perestroika conservative forces organized a coup against my leadership that failed but weakened my position Doug Mataconis: agree... Link to it will see a message like this one loyalty was tenuous at best, but,... Half months later, the whole Union part of the keyboard shortcuts it had drawback... Choices for some kind of imperialist nonsense I would argue that Stalin, is made. Are intimidated, people are murdered by connected gangs, and the communist-era policies of the United states could resist. From 1894 until his forced abdication in 1917 in the Cold war even forthright defenses of the Union was,. Impossible even for the United states he made changes that made Soviet citizens want even more freedom his never... All heavy industry the Soviet Union relied on early on started to fall apart and could... Union part of the United states is imperialist feeds, and then four and a half months,. We just call the proconsuls “ generals ” what, you agree to our use of cookies and!